Size Matters Charters Customer Reviews

Name: Size Matters Charters
Brand: Size Matters Charters
Rating: 5 (42 reviews)

100% would recommend

5/5

From 42
verified reviews

Jack AI Customer Experience Snapshot

Captain Regina consistently puts customers on productive fishing spots throughout Islamorada waters, with guests regularly catching yellowtail snapper, mahi-mahi, blackfin tuna, and amberjack. She demonstrates excellent local knowledge by visiting multiple locations during trips, from reefs and wrecks to deeper blue water for trolling. Customers appreciate her ability to target specific species like the bucket-list blackfin tuna, and many report limiting out on yellowtail snapper with catches of 12-20 fish per trip. Regina creates a relaxed, welcoming atmosphere that works especially well for families and first-time charter customers. She and her mates take extra time with children, teaching them proper techniques for dropping bait and recognizing bites. Guests consistently mention thoughtful touches like fish cleaning, complimentary Size Matters t-shirts, and restaurant recommendations for hook-and-cook services. Multiple customers specifically mention returning for repeat trips and booking again next year.

AI-generated from the text of customer reviews

Yellowtail Snapper

Mahi-Mahi

Blackfin Tuna

Family-Friendly

Fish Cleaning

Knowledgeable

Relaxed Atmosphere

Repeat Customers

Photos from Real Customers

See all images

Fresh caught Great Barracuda and Mahi Mahi displayed on cleaning station table at marina

Four people on a boat enjoying a day out on the water with blue sky and clouds in background

Sharks swimming through a large school of fish in deep blue ocean water

Fresh caught yellowfin fish lined up on boat deck after successful fishing trip

Fresh caught yellowfin fish lined up on fishing boat deck after successful fishing trip

Three people fishing in an unspecified location

10 blue runner fish caught while fishing

11 grey snapper fish caught during a fishing trip

5 great barracuda fish caught while fishing

Book Your Next Trip With Us

All Reviews

Glen-michael Hepworth

June 7, 2026

Trip - Extended Half Day Fishing Charter In Islamorada, FL - Tuna, Grouper, Wahoo, Mahi Mahi on June 6, 2026

7:30 AM - 1:30 PM

Max 3 guests

Catches : 3

Yellowfin
Catches: 1
Lane Snapper
Catches: 1
Great Barracuda
Catches: 1

We came for Mahi, and weren't disappointed. The captain was great, very knowledgeable and personable, you could tell she loved doing this. We had a great time, caught lots of fish, and left with more food than we could eat! Would highly recommend!

Was this helpful ?

Barbara Denney

June 5, 2026

Trip - Half Day Guided Fishing Charter In Islamorada - Snapper, Mackerel, Barracuda on May 22, 2026

7:30 AM - 11:30 AM

Max 2 guests

Captain Regina, thank you for a wonderful trip. Everything was perfect and our yellowtail snappers were delicious for dinner. I’m highly going to recommend you to family and friends. It was a great experience hope to see you again sometime soon. You and Tony were the best 😎. Barbara and Jerry

Was this helpful ?

Doug Craige

May 1, 2026

Trip - Half Day Wreck And Reef Fishing Charter In Islamorada - Snapper, Barracuda, Mackerel on May 1, 2026

7:30 AM - 1:30 PM

Max 3 guests

Had a great day! Limited on snapper. Very personable captain and mate. Very comfortable boat. Thank you for a great trip. Doug

Was this helpful ?

Doug Craige

May 1, 2026

Trip - Half Day Wreck And Reef Fishing Charter In Islamorada - Snapper, Barracuda, Mackerel on May 1, 2026

7:30 AM - 1:30 PM

Max 3 guests

Was this helpful ?

Nick Holm

December 31, 2025

Trip - Full Day Guided Fishing Trip In Islamorada - Tuna, Wahoo, Mahi-Mahi on December 29, 2025

7:00 AM - 3:00 PM

Max 3 guests

Fun trip with great Capt and crew. Highly recommend and would go again!

Was this helpful ?

Charles Ackman

December 16, 2025

Trip - Extended Half Day Fishing Charter In Islamorada, FL - Tuna, Grouper, Wahoo, Mahi Mahi on December 11, 2025

7:30 AM - 1:30 PM

Max 2 guests

Great experience. Capt and crew were knowledgeable and attentive! Would definitely go back.

Was this helpful ?

Rick Boarman

January 21, 2025

Trip - Half Day Wreck And Reef Fishing Charter In Islamorada - Snapper, Barracuda, Mackerel on January 21, 2025

7:30 AM - 11:30 AM

Max 1 guest

Had a great time. Caught more than enough fish to feed four of us. Gina made sure we were taken care of. Will be back.

Was this helpful ?

Elizabeth Felts Akus

October 12, 2024

Trip - on October 12, 2024

My Husband and I booked a trip with Captain Regina and had a great experience. She did everything she could to put us on the fish. We had a great time and caught a mahi! Thank you, Captain Regina!

Was this helpful ?

Tavis Walker

September 30, 2024

Trip - Half Day Wreck And Reef Fishing Charter In Islamorada - Snapper, Barracuda, Mackerel on September 29, 2024

7:30 AM - 11:30 AM

Max 6 guests

This is the first for me and my dad. We caught fish as soon as we got out there. Capt’n and Henry are great. If we come back we will be booking again! Thank you guys!!

Guide responseWas this helpful ?

Captain ReginaReplied on September 30, 2024

Tavis Walker, Thank you! You guys were awesome. Looking forward to our next trip. Thanks for donating your catch!!

Zack W

May 21, 2024

Trip - on May 21, 2024

Regina and her crew are fantastic! We caught so many fish and had an amazing time. I highly recommend giving them a try—you'll have an unforgettable experience.

Was this helpful ?

Tyler Norum

May 9, 2024

Trip - on May 9, 2024

Had an awesome time on the water with the Size Matters crew. They were very knowledgeable and hard-working and they put us on lots of fish. Highly recommend.

Was this helpful ?

Chris G

April 25, 2024

Trip - on April 25, 2024

Regina and Henry were incredibly attentive and wonderful! We would recommend Size Matters to anyone looking to charter a fishing trip. It was a fantastic experience, and we're already looking forward to next year!

Was this helpful ?

Top Rated Fishing Charter in Islamorada

About Size Matters Charters Business Reviews

Size Matters Charters has truly captured the hearts of fishing enthusiasts, as evident in the myriad of five-star reviews and exuberant feedback from their delighted guests. The Florida fishing experience offered by Size Matters Charters is nothing short of exhilarating – a captivating dance with the deep sea fishing, where every cast holds the promise of an unforgettable adventure. Guests have raved about the thrill of reeling in trophy-sized catches while being guided by the skilled and charismatic crew. The joy and excitement radiate through the words of these reviews, painting a picture of epic battles with marlins, the triumphant struggle with powerful tuna, and the sheer awe of encountering majestic sea creatures up close. Size Matters Charters has truly mastered the art of turning inshore fishing into an electrifying journey that etches itself into the memory, leaving every angler with a profound sense of fulfillment and a longing to return to the open waters for more exhilarating escapades.

Size Matters Charters Customer Reviews are provided by our guests. We focus on providing our Islamorada, FL Fishing Charter guests the very best experience. Our Fishing reviews are from trips in Atlantic Ocean, Florida Bay, Florida Keys, West Lake, Key West, Atlantic Ocean.